Archive for February, 2007

US MVNOs – what viable concepts remain?

Wednesday, February 28th, 2007

The US MVNO market has passed through infancy. Some MVNOs are entering adolescence (Virgin, Boost) while others are just starting to walk on their own (Helio, Amp’d, Disney). Discount prepaid operators are beginning to see a shakeout (see this news item). Which all begs the question: are there any new MVNO types that still have life? I think there are two:

  1. The “store-brand” MVNO – if you are a large enough retailer, with a devoted clientele, and don’t already stock other cellphones, a prepaid offering can be profitable. The prototype operator is Tesco Mobile in the UK.

  2. The cult MVNO – how do you lure customers away from the large mobile operators? One way is to have a powerful, long-lasting bond with a segment of customers. And tell them: “Buy cellphone service from us. It may cost a little more, you may have to give up a little service, but it’s worth it to support the community.” One very recent example is the launch of the Planned Parenthood MVNO.

Store-brand MVNOs will be larger, but fewer in number, since a limited number of retail channels will fulfill the criteria to host a successful MVNO. Cult MVNOs, by contrast, will serve smaller subscriber bases, but could be much more numerous.

And, of course, one significant question remains: will the operators want to enable them?

(Photo: the LG225 phone offered by Planned Parenthood Wireless)

, , , , ,

Story v. Essay

Tuesday, February 27th, 2007

It’s becoming conventional wisdom that stories are a superior form of communication for complex information, such as strategies, value of technology products, business knowledge, brand attributes, etc. (Don’t believe me? Read these: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8.)

Here’s a simple way to distinguish a story from another form of communication, the essay (which works well in other situations):

Story Essay
engages the senses engages the mind
concrete, detailed abstract/conceptual
specific general
contains moment-to- moment action. (“Thomas flicked his finger, causing his pen to twirl around his thumbnail until he caught it again.”) summarized (“Students are often bored in school.”)
suspenseful, surprising linear
uses action verbs “is”

Wait, you’re saying. Don’t some stories have the same characteristics as the essays you’re referring to?

Yes. But they’re rarely good stories.

(Picture by kaliyoda via stock.xchng)

, , , , ,

Proposing a value-adding middleman for innovation

Monday, February 26th, 2007

In March’s Harvard Business Review, Professors Mohan Sawhney of Northwestern Unversity and Satish Nambisan of Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute define a valuable emerging role in the open innovation process–what they call an “innovation capitalist.” (Free link to article.)

An IC firm would identify and license ideas and technology from various sources, and sell them to an established companies looking for new and innovative products. Yet it would do more than simply broker the idea between inventor and acquiring company.

The IC would develop prototypes, conduct market research, perform initial branding and packaging–but would stop short of fully developing or commercializing the concept. That would be left to the acquiring company.

The acquiring company pays less than it would for a market-proven product. But it also gets to observe and assess products well past the idea stage, and thus increases its innovation yield.

Product marketing consultants, you have a new job title: Innovation Capitalist.

(Disclosure: I am an RPI alumnus)

, , ,

An innovator in government communications passes away

Saturday, February 24th, 2007

Like seemingly everyone else, I’m reading Made to Stick by the Heath brothers. So today’s New York Times obituary of former CIA analyst Richard Lehman practically jumped off the page as I read it. Mr. Lehman crafted an intelligence briefing memo (the President’s Intelligence Check List, or PICL) for President John Kennedy in 1961 that replaced an assortment of confusing, redundant and often omission-filled documents.

Says the Times:

Mr. Lehman recalled how “Kennedy was blindsided a couple of times” because he had not received important briefings. The president complained to Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy, who, Mr. Lehman said, “came down on” the senior White House military aide, Maj. Gen. Chester Clifton, “like a ton of bricks.”

Mr. Lehman said General Clifton told him to produce a daily memo that would fit into a breast pocket so the president could carry it around with him. What the general wanted, Mr. Lehman said, was “a single publication, no sources barred, covering the whole ground, and written as much as possible in the president’s language rather than in officialese.”

If that isn’t following the Heaths’ simple and credible rules., I don’t know what is. And this document has remained in use for forty-five years, through eight succeeding Presidents.

Also, I must point out a very good use of concrete description in the next paragraph of the Times article: “On a Saturday morning in June 1961, President Kennedy read the first PICL while sitting on a diving board at a hunting farm in Virginia.”

Rest in peace, Mr. Lehman.

, , ,

Jon Miller’s list of B2B marketing blogs

Saturday, February 24th, 2007

My fellow Futurelab contributor Jon Miller has published a list of important B2B marketing blogs.

Jon, Shop Talk should be on your list!

, ,

Even if you’re superstitious, dates are arbitrary

Friday, February 23rd, 2007

A Friday-afternoon rantTM

Here comes 07/07/07. A very lucky day–ask Tony and Eva or other engaged couples–no? Well, no!

What about 06/06/06? Wasn’t that supposed to be the devil’s day? No again.

When will we realize that each of the numbers that makes up a date is an arbitrary creation of man, lacking any consistency or objective meaning?

AD 2000 wasn’t 2000 years after the birth of Jesus (various sources place the date between 7 B.C. and 2 B.C.). And if you don’t follow Christianity, what meaning would that number have even if it were accurately counted from Jesus’ birth?

The month/day numbers have changed as recently as 1582, when the Gregorian calendar was adopted.

It’s time to stop worrying about what’s going to happen on a specific date. Truth is, if there are fateful dates out in the cosmos, we wouldn’t be able to pinpoint them anyway. So savor the present moment.

(Picture by shadowkill via stock.xchng)

, ,

Cherish those distant connections

Thursday, February 22nd, 2007

The new book “Firing Back: How Great Leaders Rebound After Career Disasters,” excerpted in the January Harvard Business Review, says something important about personal networks.

The book, by Professors Jeffrey Sonnenfeld of Yale and Andrew Ward of the University of Georgia, cites a Stanford University study finding that far more job-seekers found positions though distant acquaintances (27.8%) than through close contacts (people whom they saw at least twice a week–16.7%). Distant contacts are more likely to know people new to you, and thereby able to create connections that didn’t exist already.

Meaning: you should cultivate acquaintances with people you meet who move in different circles. And you should keep in touch, at least once a year, with most everyone you’ve met (ask Keith Ferrazzi).

A lot of work? Yes. But your next job may depend on it.

, ,

MVNO market awakens, for a day at least

Wednesday, February 21st, 2007

If you’re an MVNO fan and tired of reading about Helio’s and Amp’d’s subscriber projections, today was a day to celebrate. Two very interesting MVNO announcements hit the wires today.

First, Planned Parenthood announced an MVNO running underneath Working Assets Wireless’ Sprint contract (significant because Sprint has been very reluctant to allow their MVNOs to re-resell their service).

Second, Titan Holdings bought one of the existing prepaid MVNOs, Ready Mobile, a part of a rollup strategy that might bring some clarity to the rat’s nest that is the US prepaid MVNO market–excepting Tracfone, Virgin and Boost.

, , ,

Listen to stories to assess organizational change

Wednesday, February 21st, 2007

Picture this. You’re VP of sales, six months into the implementation of a new sales process, and you haven’t moved your numbers one iota, after spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on systems and training and at least that much in lost productivity.

Everyone rated the classes highly, the staff uses the new lingo, the surveys indicate things are OK. But no results.

Awake late at night, by the glow of the alarm clock, you are comparing yourself to the worst sales VPs you’ve ever known, to see if you might in fact be worse than any of them.

What do you do?

First, take a deep breath. Or two, or three. Then it’s time to get the story, the real story, from the people on the front lines.

Here’s how you do it:

  1. You select a diverse group of people from across the organization who in some way affect or are affected by the new sales process.
  2. A team you select works with the individuals to ask them how they do their jobs, in detail, using concrete examples. The team records and transcribes the stories.
  3. You get the group together. Using Anecdote’s sensemaking methodology, the group finds the motives, values and assumptions underlying the stories. From there, the group discovers the several key issues that are causing the biggest impediments to the new process.
  4. You work with the group to develop interventions to help address the issues and help the new process do what it’s designed to do.
  5. You put the interventions into practice. Some are big, others are small, seemingly insignificant.
  6. You monitor the team’s rising performance. That sales process wasn’t such a lousy idea after all.

Getting the real story, and figuring out how to act on it, can be done. It will take some work and a willingness to try something new. Start off by taking the “Narrative Techniques in Business” workshop March 26 in Seattle or March 29 in Boston. Click here for registration information.

(Picture by drrivky via stock.xchng)

, , , ,

Somebody out there realizes how goofy software marketing is

Tuesday, February 20th, 2007

While preparing the prior post on HP, I came across this very sensible rant by Jeff Ventura on his blog Graceful Flavor. Jeff should be hired immediately by every software vendor to improve their marketing.

,