Report from Cape May: customers say donuts, not scones

Spending the weekend at Cape May, NJ, a seaside resort (mercifully, prior to the start of the peak summer season), was a great way to size up customer-management practices. After all, you don’t get any more commercial than the relations between resort shopowners & their visiting customers.

And the surprise is this: precisely where you’d expect the sensitivity to customer needs & wants to be most acute, it’s as dull as Walmart’s.

The best example was this. We bought a coffee at a cybercafe (surprised these even still existed) and while the barista made our drinks, she mentioned that people sometimes come in & ask her for directions to one of the other coffee shops in town. (Subtext: tourists are inconsiderate & not very bright.)

“Once we ordered donuts by mistake,” she continued. “The guy brought like 3 donuts. They sold out right away.” She motioned to the case where scones & muffins sat like statues. “And then people kept coming in & asking for the donuts, & nobody bought any of the other stuff. We made sure that never happened again. No more donuts.”

The vice president of common sense & I looked at each other, thinking the same thing. I said, “I don’t know. If I owned this store, I think I’d order more donuts.”

The barista handed us our drinks & shrugged. “I just work here.”

It’s not fair, of course, to expect a clerk to think like an owner, but it reminded me of my four years in retail, part-time at Silliman’s and later Weed & Duryea Hardware in New Canaan, CT. There was a simple rule the buyers lived by: if something was moving, order more of it.

But small-business owners often overlook that rule in favor of another one: it’s my store, & people should buy what I put on display.

The next time that feeling comes over you, remember this story, and order more donuts.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Blogplay

Tags: , , ,

  • http://www.deniseleeyohn.com/bites denise lee yohn

    i don't know, john — at first it seems so logical — customers want donuts, the store should sell them.

    but what if the owners have a thing against donuts but they're passionate about scones? — or they can't find a place to provide them with donuts which are clearly different and better than other outlets so they can't sustain the price premium they need to? — or donuts give the place a cheaper feel than scones do (i have nothing against donuts, love them in fact, but they're generally more downscale than scones) — or…

    the reasons why donuts aren't right for this place might go on and on — so should the owners do donuts just because customers want them, or should they do what they're most passionate about/what they do best?

    now that i really think about it, the answer doesn't seem that obvious — you?

  • http://caddellinsightgroup.com jmcaddell

    Hi, Denise, it may not be an obvious answer, but owners defying the wishes
    of their patrons is a significant danger to businesses of all stripes and
    sizes – and especially for small businesses and startups. Being wedded to
    one's initial idea in the face of evidence to the contrary may work for some
    companies (Apple comes to mind), but for most everyone else a little
    flexibility is in order, I would say.

    To me, the moment when an entrepreneur's ideas collide with the market is
    the most critical moment in a company's birth. What are customers saying?
    What are they paying for? What do they hate? And, finally, how do you
    adjust?

blog comments powered by Disqus