Posts Tagged ‘shouting’

Pro social media, anti shouting

Thursday, September 24th, 2009

Last week, a client of mine referred me to someone who needs help figuring out how to incorporate social media into his marketing mix. “You know,” my client said, “I don’t even know if you like doing this work, because you never talk about it. But you helped me a lot and I think you can help this guy.”

The conversation made me confront why I don’t talk much about helping people with social media, and why it’s not a big part of my website or this blog (though it does sneak in from time to time).

One reason is that it seems that everyone in marketing today calls themselves “social media consultants.” And many of these consultants (snake-oil salesmen?) want to teach you how to shout at prospects, how to coerce people into joining your network, and other strategies (I use that term loosely) that to me are ineffective and basically bad, offensive marketing. Someone, say, like this guy:

So what do I do to help people in social media? I won’t tweet for you. I won’t write a sponsored post for you. I will talk to you about what you do, who your customers are & how they use social media. We’ll have a discussion about whether and how you could reach them using social media, whether there are ways to find customers or service your existing customers using these tools, and whether, frankly, you and your company really want to engage with customers this way (not everyone does).

At the end, you might see social media as something that can help your business, or you might think it has no value to your business at all. But you won’t feel sleazy, and your ears won’t be ringing from shouting.

Guaranteed.

Related posts:
The 5 Archetypal Business Twitter Strategies
John Quelch minipodcast: Why marketing is seen as unseemly

Memo to marketers: stop shouting

Tuesday, June 30th, 2009

When Billy Mays died over the weekend, his Times obituary observed that

Mr. Mays learned his craft on the Atlantic City Boardwalk, where he drew crowds as he hawked his mops and other wares. His big break came in the mid-1990s when he was hired by Orange Glo International to appear on the Home Shopping Network to promote the company’s line of cleaners, which included OxiClean, Orange Glo and Kaboom.

I liked Billy Mays; in fact, we have some OxiClean and Mighty Putty in our closets here at home (unused, I’m pretty sure). My kids enjoyed his TV pitches. But I think that his passing is an opportunity to re-evaluate how marketers talk about their products.

Because despite the new community-building and discussion tools the internet has provided us, we marketers still communicate more like Atlantic City barkers than friends or businesspeople.

Consider the state of marketing messaging.

Send Sales Rep Productivity Sky-High
*

Nokia Saudi Arabia Capitalizes On Its Revolutionary Software & Solutions To Redefine Mobile Use**

Illumina Introduces Breakthrough Software Advancements with Genome AnalyzerIIx Sequencing System***

Just cut, activate and apply Mighty Putty™ to fix, fill or seal almost any surface!

There is one powerful similarity between Billy Mays’ pitches and the “serious” press release headlines above. Their purpose is to get our attention. “Revolutionary!” “Breakthrough!” But these words have lost their meaning through overuse and underdelivery–no one believes them anymore. [There's also one striking difference--Mighty Putty has Billy Mays, a real person, who you can laugh with, remember, and even mourn.]

Isn’t it time to retire “breakthrough” and “revolutionary” marketing copy for B2B products?

Granted that there’s a lot of noise out there about all products, but there are far better and more effective ways of finding and engaging with customers than adding your voice to the chorus of shouters.

* salesforce.com
** Nokia
*** Illumina